Gregory's Page

Website	UpToDate	Medscape	Neonatology	Neonatology Today	NICU University	Drager	Quizlet
Who wrote the material? Is their an author? Who is the author? What are the authors credentials Is the author an expert in the field? Has the author published other work? If the author is an organization or institution, are they reputable?	Yes the Authors and editor`s names are listed They are all reputable physicians and work in the field of neonatology Have published multiple papers and other topics on UpToDate	Yes the authors, chief editor and contributors names are present They are all Physicians working and teaching in pediatrics They have stated that they have nothing to disclose Additional information is provided with medical societies they are members of	Yes the authors of the articles names are present They are all Physicians working and teaching in pediatrics A Google search, provides additional information, resumes and other publications. They have stated that they have nothing to disclose	Yes the authors of the articles “NAVA Ventilation in Neonates: Clinical Guidelines and Management Strategies” are stated The authors are a Physicians and respiratory therapist who clinically work with NAVA The authors have published multiple papers on the topic and H Stein is regarded as one of the leading experts in the field	The authors and their credentials are listed A Google search on various authors on the website provides information that allows the assumption that they are reputable and credible The authors are well published on the topic	The authors and their credentials for the CE programs are listed The authors are credible and leaders in the field The authors are well published and the website provides the authors CV	The authors of the flash cards/quizzes names are present The Authors are students and/or teachers
What is the purpose of the website? Who created the website? Is it a person, institution or organization? What is the purpose of the website, is it factual, educational or fictional?	The site is evidence-based, physician authored, educational site It is a clinical decision support resource that is meant to help clinicians care for their patients	The site is an evidence-based, educational site Provide educational information to health care providers	This is a refutable medical journal The article is a European Consensus Guidelines on the Management of Neonatal Respiratory Distress Syndrome in Preterm Infants – 2010 Update	The article is published in a NEONATOLOGY TODAY a free monthly newsletter Its purpose is to provide neonatologist with news and information	There is no information on who the administrator of the website. There is information provided to contact the website The website states that it provides educational and informational resources to clinicians There website provides certified education (CE) programs which health care provides can receive credit for	The website is created by a ventilator company; Drager Medical The purpose of this part of the website is to provide education and webinars.	Quizlet provides free learning tools to help students
When was the information published? When was the information created? When was the information last updated?	There is no creation date, however the review states it was last updated in Oct 2012, and was reviewed for currency in Sept 2014	There is no creation date, however the review states it was last updated in Sept 2012	The article was published in June 2010	The article was published in April 2012	The dates of the certified education programs are provided on the website	There are no dates visible for when the online continuing education courses were created	The date the information is created is present. However I cannot find any information about updates
Where did the information come from? What supports the information found on the website? Is there a reference list?	The information is evidence based and referenced	The information is evidence based and referenced	The information provided is evidence based and referenced	The information provided is evidence based and referenced	The CE programs are evidence based and references are provided	The information provided is by experts in the field, some of the webinars are adequately references, however some of the webinars do not contain or provide reference information	There is no support or referencing of information found on the website
Why should I trust the information? Is the information biased or does it push a specific agenda? Does the site contain advertising? Is there any conflict of interest between with advertisements or site supporting organizations?	Yes the information found on this site is trustworthy and up to date (as the name suggests). There is no bias, advertising or conflict	The information found on this site is trustworthy and evidence based There appears to be no bias in the information provided, however the site does contain advertising	The information found in the paper is evidence based There appears to be no bias in the information provided, however the site does contain advertising	The information found in the paper is evidence based As this is a free newsletter the site is heavily advertised Although there is no mention of it, the authors would most likely have a close relationship with the ventilator company	The information found in the paper is evidence based Each presentation provides information and disclaimers of the website and the presenter The website has multiple sponsors and advertisements	For the majority of the presentations, the authors provides disclosures. Many have received funding or provided work for Drager Medical. The information learnt in the webinars must be assessed for bias on an individual basis due to the fact that is provided by a medical company.	The information provided on the website needs to be taken for what it is. There are many quizzes that students can access. To help improve the accuracy of the information I can create learning tools on Quizlet for my students and this will increase the reliability of the information

I focused on the topic Neonatal Respiratory Distress Syndrome (RDS). RDS is a disease that affects premature babies. Premature babies born less than 37 weeks gestation lack a compound in their lungs called surfactant (Sweet et. al., 2010). Without surfactant, these babies struggle to breath and many may die without appropriate treatment.

A variety of web based resources were used to prepare for this topic. In the medical field, evidence based peer reviewed literature is considered the gold standard. UpToDate and Medscape provide an excellent overview of the pathology, diagnosis, and treatment options for RDS. These sites provide a foundation that the students can use as a base to build their knowledge on the management of RDS. The article in Neonatology journal titled “European Consensus Guidelines on the Management of Neonatal Respiratory Distress Syndrome in Preterm Infants – 2010 Update” further outlines the clinical management of RDS based on evidence based literature. These three resources provide the educators a framework for teaching of the topic and are valuable resources for the students.

Another important learning tool is the use of continuing education (CE) webinars available to students. There are a variety of CE webinars available on Drager Medical, a popular neonatal ventilator company, and NICUniversity. The webinars can be watched in class or at home by students and are also available on tablets to provide easier access. Upon completion of the webinars, there are questions available for the students to answer, and if correctly answered the students are presented with a certificate of completion. The webinars are often led by international experts in the medical field and provide the students with clinical experience that is often lost in textbooks or webpages. Although the Drager Medical webinars are often biased as they are developed to promote their ventilators, they provide valuable information about how to effectively use their products. It is difficult to obtain this information elsewhere.

The final resource I analyzed was Quizlet. The website is an educational tool where the teacher and/or students can create questions, quizzes and flashcards to help with studying and understanding of the material. Students also have the option of looking at other topics and subsets created by other groups.

I have focused on a range of learning resources to provide students with a valuable learning experience and to cover a variety of different learning styles. Resources examined include medical journals, newsletters and continuing education programs. A resource not available that would strengthen students learning on RDS is an interactive patient case studies website – this would enable students to develop critical analysis skills as required for effective management of their patients.

References:

Sweet D, G, Carnielli V, Greisen G, Hallman M, Ozek E, Plavka R, Saugstad O, D, Simeoni U, Speer C, P, Halliday H, L, European Consensus Guidelines on the Management of Neonatal Respiratory Distress Syndrome in Preterm Infants – 2010 Update. Neonatology 2010;97:402-417