Difference between revisions of "Gregory's Page"

From Kumu Wiki - TRU
Jump to navigation Jump to search
Line 36: Line 36:
 
* The authors are credible and leaders in the field  
 
* The authors are credible and leaders in the field  
 
* The authors are well published on and the website provides the authors CV  
 
* The authors are well published on and the website provides the authors CV  
|| Example
+
||  
 +
* The authors of the flash cards/quizzes names are present
 +
* The Authors are students and/or teachers 
 +
 
 
|-
 
|-
  
Line 63: Line 66:
 
* The website is created by a ventilator company; Drager medical  
 
* The website is created by a ventilator company; Drager medical  
 
* The purpose of this part of the website is to provide education and webinars.   
 
* The purpose of this part of the website is to provide education and webinars.   
|| Example
+
||  
 +
* Quizlet provides free learning tools to help students   
 
|-
 
|-
  
Line 82: Line 86:
 
||  
 
||  
 
* There are no dates visible for when the online continuing education courses were creates  
 
* There are no dates visible for when the online continuing education courses were creates  
  || Example
+
  ||  
 +
* The date the information is created is present. However I cannot find any information about updates 
 
|-
 
|-
  
Line 101: Line 106:
 
  ||  
 
  ||  
 
* The information provided is by experts in the field, some of the webinars are adequately references, however some of the webinars do not contain or provide reference information  
 
* The information provided is by experts in the field, some of the webinars are adequately references, however some of the webinars do not contain or provide reference information  
  || Example
+
  ||  
 +
* There is no support or referencing of information found on the website 
 
|-
 
|-
  
Line 128: Line 134:
 
* For the majority of the presentations, the authors provides disclosures. Many have received funding or provided work for Drager Medical.   
 
* For the majority of the presentations, the authors provides disclosures. Many have received funding or provided work for Drager Medical.   
 
* The information learnt in the webinars must be assessed for bias on an individual basis due to the fact that is provided by a medical company.     
 
* The information learnt in the webinars must be assessed for bias on an individual basis due to the fact that is provided by a medical company.     
|| Example
+
||  
 +
* The information provided on the website needs to be taken for what it is.     
 +
* There are many quizzes that students can access.
 +
* To help improve the accuracy of the information I can create learning tools on Quizlet for my students and this will increase the reliability of the information
 +
 
 
|-
 
|-
  
  
 
| '''Objectivity'''
 
Is the information presented with a minimum of bias?
 
To what extent is the resource trying to sway the opinion of the audience using rhetorical skills (appeals to emotion etc.) instead of logic?
 
|| Example || Example || Example || Example || Example || Example || Example
 
 
|}
 
|}

Revision as of 11:27, 26 October 2014

Website UpToDate Medscape Neonatology Neonatology Today NICU University Drager Quizlet
Who wrote the material?
  • Is there an author?
  • Who is the author?
  • What are the authors credentials
  • Is the author an expert in the field?
  • Has the author published other work?
  • If the author is an organization or institution, are they reputable?
  • Yes the Authors and editor`s names are listed
  • They are all reputable physicians and work in the field of neonatology
  • Have published multiple papers and other topics on UpToDate
  • Yes the authors, chief editor and contributors names are present
  • They are all Physicians working and teaching in pediatrics
  • They have stated that they have nothing to disclose
  • Additional information is provided with medical societies they are members of
  • Yes the authors of the articles names are present
  • They are all Physicians working and teaching in pediatrics
  • A Google search, provides additional information, resumes and other publications.
  • They have stated that they have nothing to disclose
  • Yes the authors of the articles “NAVA Ventilation in Neonates: Clinical Guidelines and Management Strategies” are stated
  • The authors are a Physicians and respiratory therapist who clinically work with NAVA
  • The authors have published multiple papers on the topic and H Stein is regarded as one of the leading experts in the field
  • The authors and their credentials are listed
  • A Google search on various authors on the website provides information that allows the assumption that they are reputable and credible
  • The authors are well published on the topic
  • The authors and their credentials for the CE programs are listed
  • The authors are credible and leaders in the field
  • The authors are well published on and the website provides the authors CV
  • The authors of the flash cards/quizzes names are present
  • The Authors are students and/or teachers
What is the purpose of the website?
  • Who created the website? Is it a person, institution or organization?
  • What is the purpose of the website, is it factual, educational or fictional?
  • The site is evidence-based, physician-authored educational site
  • It is a clinical decision support resource that is meant to help clinicians care for their patients
  • The site is an evidence-based, educational site
  • Provide educational information to health care providers
  • This is a refutable medical journal
  • The article is a European Consensus Guidelines on the Management of Neonatal Respiratory Distress Syndrome in Preterm Infants – 2010 Update
  • The article is published in a NEONATOLOGY TODAY a free monthly newsletter
  • Its purpose is to provide neonatologist with news and information
  • There is no information on who the administrator of the website is.
  • There is information provided to contact the website
  • The website states that it provides educational and informational resource clinicians
  • There website provides certified education programs which health care provides can receive credit for
  • The website is created by a ventilator company; Drager medical
  • The purpose of this part of the website is to provide education and webinars.
  • Quizlet provides free learning tools to help students
When was the information published?
  • When was the information created?
  • When was the information last updated?
  • There is no creation date, however the review states it was last updated in Oct 2012 and was reviewed for currency in Sept 2014
  • There is no creation date, however the review states it was last updated in Sept 2012
  • The article was published in June 2010
  • The article was published in April 2012
  • The dates of the certified education programs are provided on the website
  • There are no dates visible for when the online continuing education courses were creates
  • The date the information is created is present. However I cannot find any information about updates
Where did the information come from?
  • What supports the information found on the website?
  • If there a reference list?
  • The information is evidence based and referenced
  • The information is evidence based and referenced
  • The information provided is evidence based and referenced

The information provided is evidence based and referenced

  • The information provided is evidence based and references for the CE programs are provided
  • The information provided is by experts in the field, some of the webinars are adequately references, however some of the webinars do not contain or provide reference information
  • There is no support or referencing of information found on the website
Why should I trust the information?
  • Is the information biased or does it push a specific agenda?
  • Does the site contain advertising?
  • Is there any conflict of interest between with advertisements or site supporting organizations?
  • Yes the information found on this site is trustworthy and up to date (as the name suggests).
  • There is no bias, advertising or conflict
  • The information found on this site is trustworthy and evidence based
  • There appears to be no bias in the information provided, however the site does contain advertising
  • The information found in the paper is evidence based
  • There appears to be no bias in the information provided, however the site does contain advertising
  • The information found in the paper is evidence based
  • As this is a free newsletter the site is heavily advertised
  • Although there is no mention of it, the authors would most likely have a close relationship with the ventilator company
  • The information found in the paper is evidence based
  • Each presentation provides information and disclaimers of the website and the presenter
  • The website has multiple sponsors and advertisements
  • For the majority of the presentations, the authors provides disclosures. Many have received funding or provided work for Drager Medical.
  • The information learnt in the webinars must be assessed for bias on an individual basis due to the fact that is provided by a medical company.
  • The information provided on the website needs to be taken for what it is.
  • There are many quizzes that students can access.
  • To help improve the accuracy of the information I can create learning tools on Quizlet for my students and this will increase the reliability of the information